개정형사소송법의 증거개시 조항에 대한 비판적 고찰

• 영문명: A Critical Review about Discovery of the Revised Korean Criminal Procedure Law of 2008
• 발행기관: 한국형사법학회
• 저자명: 심회기(Sim, Hui-Gi)
• 간행물 정보: 『형사법연구』형사법연구 제20권 제4호, 311~334쪽, 전체 24쪽
• 주제분류: 법학 > 법학
• 파일형태: PDF
• 발행일자: 2008.01.27

영문 초록

Revised Korean Criminal Procedure Law of 2008 has a lot of adversarial features. One of the remarkable features is an adoption of Anglo-American style discovery and disclosure. In Part Ⅱ, I analyze the relationship between the constitutional court's decision of 1997 and the provision of newly revised criminal procedure law's discovery clauses. In Part Ⅲ of this article I explore the basic features of the provision of newly revised criminal procedure law's discovery clauses, and Part Ⅳ reviews various interpretational issues. Korea's new rule follows a global trend of expanded prosecutorial discovery in criminal cases. Prosecutors are bound, upon request, to disclose all exculpatory evidence that they are going to use at trial. This article addresses the provisions and ramifications of the new reciprocal criminal discovery rule in Korea. Although the rule provides for a “two-way street", its significance lies in its expansion of discovery by the criminal defendant. In Part Ⅴ, I tried to criticize legislative failures and flaws. A relevant discussion will be provided of the history of criminal discovery, development and present status of the rule in Korea, and a prediction of what Korean practitioners are now facing. In Part Ⅵ, I summarized my findings and proposes actions that police, prosecutors, and defense attorneys should take to ameliorate the problem. Above all, I concluded that the more strong sanctions for prosecution's violations of criminal discovery rules should be added.

목차

Ⅰ. 문제의 제기

Ⅱ. 1997년의 헌재결정과 개정법의 증거개시조항의 관련성

Ⅲ. 개정법의 증거개시조항의 전체적 성격

Ⅳ. 개정법의 해석․운용상의 쟁점들

Ⅴ. 개정법에 대한 비판적 고찰

Ⅵ. 결어

키워드

증거개시 개방적 개시론 제한적 개시론 discovery open file approach expansive discovery system limited discovery system