학술논문
원시적 불능에 관한 민법 제535조의 개정에 관한 연구
이용수 162
- 영문명
- Initial Impossibility and the Revision of Art. 535 of Korean Civil Code
- 발행기관
- 한국재산법학회
- 저자명
- 김영두(Kim, Young-Doo)
- 간행물 정보
- 『재산법연구』財産法硏究 第27卷 第1號, 241~284쪽, 전체 44쪽
- 주제분류
- 법학 > 법학
- 파일형태
- 발행일자
- 2010.06.30
8,080원
구매일시로부터 72시간 이내에 다운로드 가능합니다.
이 학술논문 정보는 (주)교보문고와 각 발행기관 사이에 저작물 이용 계약이 체결된 것으로, 교보문고를 통해 제공되고 있습니다.
국문 초록
영문 초록
According to Art. 535 of Korean Civil Code(KCC), the party who knows or should have known that the performance of contract was initially impossible is responsible for the reliance damages to the other party. Some writers are pointing out the facts that new Art. 311a of German Civil Code allows the creditor to demand expectation damages in case of initial impossibility unlike the old German Civil Code, and Principles of European Contract Law(PECL) and Principles of International Commercial Contract(PICC) make the initially impossible contract valid and allow expectation damages to the creditor. They think Art. 535 of KCC has some problems and should be revised. To decide whether it is necessary to revise Art. 535 of KCC, firstly it should be examined that it is necessary to allow the creditor to demand expectation damages in case of initial impossibility. The justification of revising Art. 535 of KCC depends on the need for allowing the creditor to demand expectation damages. In short, when the debtor knows or should have known the initial impossibility of performance, the creditor should have a right to demand expectation damages, because the act that the debtor have entered into
contract or have not informed the creditor what is concerned with the initial impossibility even though it knows or should have known the initial impossibility, is as blamable as the act that the debtor have made the
performance impossible subsequently which allows the creditor to damand expectation damages. There is no reason to differentiate the remedies between initial impossibility and subsequent impossibility. The second problem of the revision of Art. 535 of KCC is concerned with validity of contract in case of initial impossibility. Even though the contract is invalid in case of initial impossibility, there is a possibility that the creditor
could have a right of damages such as loss of profit through tortious liability. However the creditor couldn't recover the damages such as the lost value of performance itself through tortious liability. Such damages is recoverable only through contractual liability. So to allow the creditor to recover the damages sufficiently, contract should be valid in spite of the initial impossibility. If contract is valid and the creditor could recover the expectation damages in case of initial impossibility, the third problem is what is the essence of the liability of expectation damages of debtor. Such liability cannot be a liability of breach of contract, for which the fault that is concerned with the act of debtor breaching the contract is needed. But it is impossible to think of the act which amount to the breach of contract and the fault of that act in case of initial
impossibility, because the debtor has no duty to initially impossible performance. So the liability of intial impossibility should be based on the guarantee that the performance is initially possible. Under the conclusion that the creditor should have a chance to recover expectation damages and the contract should be valid in case of initial impossibility, and that such liability should be that of guarantee, directions and content of revision of Art. 535 of KCC should be organized.
목차
Ⅰ. 서론
Ⅱ. 원시적 불능론에 관한 이론적 검토
Ⅲ. 민법 제535조의 개정방향
Ⅳ. 결론
키워드
해당간행물 수록 논문
- 부당이득에서 급부, 침해 그리고 단순한 이익의 귀속
- Patents System and Negative Externalities of R&D
- 판례상 합의해지에 관한 화해
- 다수당사자의 채권관계
- 유럽계약법상 신의성실의 원칙의 내용과 우리민법의 시사점
- 자동차사고 피해자의 합의 후 사정변경에 따른 손해배상금 산정시 부당이득반환과 기판력에 관한 판례연구
- 원시적 불능에 관한 민법 제535조의 개정에 관한 연구
- 민․상법의 통일적 법제도의 정비를 위한 조건
- 예금채권으로 된 압류금지채권에 대한 압류 및 상계에 관한 소고
- 不動産 二重賣買에 관한 立法論的 考察
- 아파트 분양 광고와 시공사의 법적 책임
- 福祉型信託 導入을 통한 民事信託의 活性化
- 단체보험계약에 관한 소고
- 중화인민공화국 물권법(2007년)의 물권변동에 관한 연구
- 環境侵害의 留止請求
참고문헌
관련논문
최근 이용한 논문
교보eBook 첫 방문을 환영 합니다!
신규가입 혜택 지급이 완료 되었습니다.
바로 사용 가능한 교보e캐시 1,000원 (유효기간 7일)
지금 바로 교보eBook의 다양한 콘텐츠를 이용해 보세요!