Otte Jespersen과 Otto Funke

• 발행기관: 한국영어학학회
• 저자명: 송경안
• 간행물 정보: 『영어학연구』영어학연구 제15호, 81~98쪽, 전체 18쪽
• 주제분류: 어문학 > 영어와문학
• 파일형태: PDF
• 발행일자: 2003.06.01

국문 초록

Song, Kyung-An. 2003. Otto Jespersen and Otto Funke. English Language and Llngulstlcs 15, 81-97. This paepr surveys the linguistic debate between the contemporaries, Otto Jespersen, a Dane, and Otto Funke, a German, and takes a glance at a part of academic career of Jespersen. The debate between the two scholars was initiated by Funke's review of the philosoplty of Grammar, to which jespersen replied. Funke again answered with a short critique of the reply. The critique included two main points. First, he criticized Jespersen's classification of three areas of languager form, meaning and function. He argued that Jespersen's concepl "funclion" was not very clear, and the two other categories were sufficient. Funke additionally criticized jespersen's theory of three ranks. He argued that the three ranks applied to the noun phrase, but not to the other areas such as nexus relations. Funke's critiques seems to be reasonable. At the same time, however, Jespcrsen's concepts appear to be worth keeping. Though they are somewhat vague and unclear, as is often the case with the terms or the concepts of the traditional grammar, they might have their own roles for the linguistic dcscription. Key words: Jespersen, Funke, three ranks, parts of speech, Philosoplty of Grammar