ICSID 상소제도의 도입 필요성

• 영문명: The Necessity for Introduction of ICSID Appellate System
• 발행기관: 한국중재학회
• 저자명: 김용일(Kim, Yong Il)
• 간행물 정보: 『중재연구』 제29권 제4호, 187~210쪽, 전체 24쪽
• 주제분류: 사회과학 > 무역학
• 파일형태: PDF
• 발행일자: 2019.12.30

영문 초록

This article examines the necessity for the introduction of an ICSID Appellate System. In comparison with the WTO appellate system, the ICSID ad hoc Committee has a very limited mandate. An annulment inquiry under the ICSID arbitration system barely focuses on whether the arbitral decision resulted from a justifiable process. As long as there is procedural legitimacy, the resulting awards remain unaffected under the annulment procedure, irrespective of mistakes of fact or law. In contrast, in the WTO DSS the AB substantively reviews panel rulings and suggestions that are founded on any deficiency of objectivity or error in the interpretation of a particular WTO provision. This defect intrinsic in the annulment procedure could cause injustice to a party earnestly interested in correcting recognized misapplication of law by ICSID tribunals. Accordingly, the establishment of an appellate system would result in a more substantive and procedural review of awards. The creation of such an ICSID appellate system would ensure thorough scrutiny of the decisions of the tribunal of first instance, leading to better reasoned outcomes. This could lead to a crystallization of predictability in investment relations. The end result would be that fairness, clarity, reliability, and legality in the ICSID adjudicative process would be unassailable, to the advantage of all the contracting parties.

목차

Ⅰ. 서 론

Ⅱ. WTO 상소제도

Ⅲ. ICSID 취소제도의 한계

Ⅳ. ICSID 상소제도의 도입과 문제점

Ⅴ. 결론

키워드

국제투자분쟁 WTO 분쟁해결기구 WTO 상소제도 ICSID 상소제도 ICSID 특별위원회 International Investment Disputes WTO Dispute Settlement Body WTO Appellate Body ICSID Appellate System ICSID Ad hoc Committee