학술논문
채권자대위소송의 실질적 보장과 중복소송
이용수 76
- 영문명
- Substantial Protection for Subrogation Action by Creditor and Duplicative Litigation
- 발행기관
- 경희법학연구소
- 저자명
- 범경철(Beom, Kyung-Chul)
- 간행물 정보
- 『경희법학』제45권 제4호, 95~124쪽, 전체 30쪽
- 주제분류
- 법학 > 민법
- 파일형태
- 발행일자
- 2010.12.30
6,400원
구매일시로부터 72시간 이내에 다운로드 가능합니다.
이 학술논문 정보는 (주)교보문고와 각 발행기관 사이에 저작물 이용 계약이 체결된 것으로, 교보문고를 통해 제공되고 있습니다.
국문 초록
영문 초록
There is a dispute about whether or not a creditor should be included in the concept of third party standing. The general view and the case law have approved a statutory standing over the creditor and consequently, the requirements for the subrogation action should be examined at the level of litigation requirements and the lawsuit has been dismissed without considering the merits of the claim based on the ground of duplicative litigation. However, according to a literal interpretation, a party in subrogation action asserts his or her own rights allowed under the civil law which is a substantive law.
Therefore, as to a legal relationship created by a debtor who is the subject of the right, a creditor is a person who files a lawsuit for his or her own interest. In other words, when both the subject of the right and creditor possess the right to perform a litigation,
I think it is improper to interpret the creditor as a litigant with statutory standing. Also, an interpretation separated from the substantive law in interpretation of the subrogation action seems to be too artful.
In addition, the interpretation under the case law seems to be unfair compare to creditor’s right of revocation, which is also a substantive right. In case of creditor’s right of revocation, the court took a position that a lawsuit filed by another creditor while a creditor’s revocation action is pending in court is not a duplicative litigation because the
creditor can separately assert his or her own right. Also, in judging litigation requirements, the court abusively and broadly applied the general principle to avoid duplicative litigation for the procedural stability.
Furthermore, allowing prohibitive effect on subrogation action on the ground of duplicative litigation unreasonably regulates the constitutional right of trial by the court’s interpretation. That is, the court’s dismissal of the case without considering the merits of the claim, even if the creditor in subrogation action also has a right to file a lawsuit and
develop a trial by actively proving his or her own right in a trial on the merits of a case, is unreasonably restricting a right to an action by the court’s interpretation. Therefore, the creditor in a subrogation action by creditor should be understood as a litigant with an independent standing rather than substituting the debtor.
목차
l. 머리말
ll. 채권자대위소송 일반
lll. 채권자대위소송의 개시
lV. 채권자대위소송과 중복소제기 금지
V. 채권자대위소송과 재판청구권
Vl. 맺는말
키워드
해당간행물 수록 논문
- The Present Status of Development of Nuclear Energy and Policy Issues for Green Energy in Germany
- Present status of industrial utilization of nuclear energy and legal adjustment strategy for activation in Russia
- 사이버공간상 프라이버시 개념의 변화와 그에 대한 법적 대응방안
- The Present Status of Industrial Utilization of Nuclear Energy and Adjustment Strategy for Activation in the United States of America
- The present status of the debate of the use of nuclear power in Australia
- 就業規則制度의 比較法的 一考察
- Regulatory System related to Industrial Utilizations of Nuclear Energy in Korea
- The Present Status of Development of Nuclear Energy and Policy Issues for Green Energy in China
- Present Status and Prospects:
- 집합건물의 대지공유와 그 분할의 청구
- 경희법학 제45권 제4호 목차
- 병원개설자의 조직의무와 책임근거
- 东亚地区侵权法实现一体化的基础及研究任务
- 계약해제의 요건에 관한 비교법적 고찰과 입법론적 쟁점
- 특경법 제3조 제1항의 ‘이득액’ 평가에 대한 검토
- 이상정, 「미술과 법」
- A Critical Appraisal of Current Nuclear Energy Law & Policy in Japan:
- 제사주재자의 결정방법에 관한 小考
- Liability for Nuclear Harm under the German Atomic Energy Act
- 통신의 비밀보장에 관한 연구
- LES POLITIQUES ET LE DROIT DE L’ÉNERGIE NUCLÉAIRE EN FRANCE
- 發 刊 辭
- 채권자대위소송의 실질적 보장과 중복소송
참고문헌
관련논문
최근 이용한 논문
교보eBook 첫 방문을 환영 합니다!
신규가입 혜택 지급이 완료 되었습니다.
바로 사용 가능한 교보e캐시 1,000원 (유효기간 7일)
지금 바로 교보eBook의 다양한 콘텐츠를 이용해 보세요!