채권자대위소송에서의 피대위채권의 기판력

• 발행기관: 한국민사소송법학회
• 저자명: 이동률
• 간행물 정보: 『민사소송』제26권 제1호, 171~200쪽, 전체 30쪽
• 주제분류: 법학 > 법학
• 파일형태: PDF
• 발행일자: 2022.02.28

영문 초록

An obligee may, in order to preserve his claim, exercise the rights belonging to the obligor(Civil Law Article 404). There are two rights in the Obligee s Right of Subrogation to Obligor. One is the Obligee s right which is called the Right belonging to the obligor. The other is the obligor s rights to the third obligor, which is called the counterparty. This article introduces the Supreme Court cases regarding res judicata of the Right belonging to the obligor. The analysis of these cases presented theoretical contradiction between the Supreme Court cases when the lawsuit is subsequently filed against the same rights. The main contents of this article is as follows. (ⅰ) In the first Action, the obligee sued the third obligor for the right belonging to the obligor. In the second lawsuit, the Obligor filed a lawsuit against the third obligor claiming the same rights established in the first lawsuit. The Supreme Court ruling says that the res judicata of the Action for Obligee`s Right of Subrogation to Obligor in the former lawsuit also affects the latter lawsuit if the obligor knew the lawsuit in the former lawsuit. (ⅱ) After the final judgment between the obligor and the third obligor, it is a question of whether the res judicata of the former lawsuit can be applied when the Obligee files a the Obligee’s subrogation action against the third obligor. (ⅲ) It is a question of whether the res judicata of the former lawsuit can be applied another the Obligee’s subrogation action.

목차

Ⅰ. 서론

Ⅱ. 채권자대위소송의 소송요건과 소송물

Ⅲ. 전소가 대위소송이고, 후소가 채무자의 본인소송인 경우

Ⅳ. 전소가 채무자의 본인소송이고, 후소가 대위소송인 경우

Ⅴ. 전･후 양소가 대위소송이고, 전소의 기판력이 있는 경우

Ⅵ. 결론

키워드

채권자대위소송 기판력 피대위채권 당사자적격 채무자의권리 불행사 oblique action Res judicata The right belonging to the obligor standing to sue obligor’s failure to exercise the right