三虞와 卒哭의 同異에 대한 小考

• 영문명: Similarities and Differences between Samwoo(三虞) and Jolgock(卒哭) : An Exploratory Study
• 발행기관: 동방한문학회
• 저자명: 李霜芽(Lee, Sang-ah)
• 간행물 정보: 『동방한문학』제59호, 1~17쪽, 전체 17쪽
• 주제분류: 인문학 > 문학
• 파일형태: PDF
• 발행일자: 2014.06.30

영문 초록

Samwoo(三虞) and Jolgock(卒哭) are two kinds of proprieties of mourning decorums. In conventional thinking people have viewed these proprieties as separate memorial ceremonies. This viewpoint was derived from the interpretation of Li Jing(禮經) by Jeong Hyun(鄭玄) of the Later Han Dynasty and thus overturned the existing conventional idea. However, O Gyegong(敖繼公) of Yüan Dynasty insisted that Samwoo(三虞) and Jolgock(卒哭) were the same memorial ceremonies which commemorate the same day. Raising questions of the Jeong Hyun(鄭玄)’s interpretation it continued to provoke controversy at the peak of the Ching Dynasty. There were; however, a few scholars in the Joseon Dynasty who insisted that the two ceremonies were the same.The purpose of this paper is to examine the cause of the controversy and inquire if the bases of the two sides are valid respectively. First of all, I examined the primary meaning of Samwoo(三虞) and Jolgock(卒哭) based on the original text. Then I illuminated how China and the Joseon Dynasty understood the similarities and the differences of Samwoo(三虞) and Jolgock(卒哭) and investigated the weakness of the two theories. Finally, I found that current arguments were derived not from the base of Li Jing(禮經) but instead were based on the various interpretations of the book. Therefore, I propose that the conventional idea of viewing the two ceremonies differently is not an immutable theory. Besides, the identical theory can be embraced and arrives at a common view when the majority approve that the interpretation of the original book. As a result, the ritual can also be changed following the new viewpoint. We hardly have conclusive evidence but I find that the ancient interpretation before Jeong Hyun(鄭玄) which considered the two ceremonies as the same seems to be more natural to spite the pros and cons respectively.

목차

1. 문제제기

2. 虞와 卒哭의 原義

3. 삼우 졸곡 부동설

4. 삼우 졸곡 동일설

5. 결론

참고문헌

키워드

Samwoo Jolgock Ujae Dasan Jeong Yakyong Hanjoo Lee Jinsang 三虞 卒哭 虞祭 茶山 丁若鏞 寒洲 李震相